Rule One: There Are No Rules

Margaret Lucke and her books

by Margaret Lucke

“There are 3 rules for writing a novel,” British novelist W. Somerset Maugham once announced. Then, to the disappointment of writers everywhere, he added, “Unfortunately no one knows what they are.”

If only there were rules, a way to know for sure that if you just do this, this, and this, your book will be a success.

I just finished teaching a course called The Craft of Writing for UC Berkeley Extension, where I’ve taught for many years. The students were a talented group, and I’m sure that if they persevere, they will succeed as writers. I gave them tips, tricks, feedback, and guidelines. But what I couldn’t give them was guarantees.

In every class, some of the students love the idea of having complete freedom to write however they please, while others crave the comfort of having defined rules and structures to adhere to. And no, I can’t tell which attitude produces the best writers. I’ve read brilliant work and terrible work from both groups.

At the start of the first class, I explain that while the classroom has a few rules (summarized in the statement Be respectful of others), writing does not. Then I proceed to give them some anyway, only I call them reminders. Why is that? See Number 1.

1. There are no rules. As the instructor my role is to provide suggestions, observations, and insights that might be helpful. I’ll explain what has and hasn’t worked for me and for other writers I know. But writing is a trial-and-error process—all writers have to discover what works for them. I think of a class as being like a smorgasbord, where you can sample the ideas that suit your own appetites. The only thing you can be certain of is that no matter what you’re told about how to write good fiction, you’ll find outstanding novels and short stories that do it a different way.

2.  There is no magic formula for how to write or what to write. One time, during the lunch break of an all-day seminar, I heard one of the participants grumble to another, “This class is just like all the others. They never tell you the secret. The published writers always keep it to themselves.”

That’s because there is no secret, no wand you can wave, no wizardly trick, no abracadabra to mutter. Part of growing as a writer is discovering your own passions, and developing your own sense of what works for you and why. And being willing to get muddy in process. As novelist Margaret Atwood has observed: “In school … you probably got the idea that the novelist had an overall scheme or idea and then went about colouring it in with characters and words, sort of like paint-by-numbers. But in reality the process is much more like wrestling a greased pig in the dark.”

3. You don’t have to get it right the first time—there’s a wonderful invention called the second draft. Or more—it’s said that Ernest Hemingway rewrote the ending to A Farewell to Arms 47 times. The trick is to figure out what your story is and concentrate on getting it down on paper (or the electronic equivalent) in all its raw, creative glory. Plugging the plot holes and refining the language can come later. If you put your internal editor in charge too soon, you’ll have desk drawers full of half-written stories.

4.  If you don’t write your book, it won’t get written. No one else can do it for you. There’s a saying among writers: “I don’t want to write. I want to have written.” But you can’t reach to that second place until you’ve gone through the first one. Time management experts are big on delegation, but writing your novel is one endeavor you can’t turn over to someone else. Which brings us to the final rule:

5.  Apply seat of pants. I got this advice long ago from a mentor of mine, the late screenwriter Lawrence Menkin. It means you need to put the seat of your pants on the seat of your chair, with your work in progress in front of you. If you don’t do that, no writing rules or lack thereof will matter.

After all, as writer Rick Bylina puts it: “The only rule: writers write! Everything else is a guideline.”

Thankful

It’s November the month when we have a small thing called Thanksgiving. Whether you sit down with family, friends, or just yourself it seems to be the day when we think about all we are thankful for.

Of course, Thanksgiving is one of those holidays that has been spun to make us be grateful for what we have. Which is wonderful, but we, well I know I wouldn’t be here, if it hadn’t been for the Native Americans who back in 1621 helped the pilgrims make it through that first winter in North America. According to my grandmother, I have an ancestor who came over on the Mayflower. If they hadn’t lived, who knows who I would have turned out to be. Which makes me grateful that the people who lived here were willing to share with the ones who invaded their land.

I’m thankful to have been born in the decade where we have lived through so many good inventions. But lately a few too many that I’m not so excited about. I feel their need to “help us or make things easier” is making use dumber.

Being a kid in the 60’s & 70’s was like being a feral animal. LOL During the summer, I could do my chores, saddle up my horse and be gone all day riding on the mountainside. As long as I made it home to do my afternoon chores and have dinner ready when my parents got home from work, they didn’t care what I did all day. And they didn’t worry harm would come to me or my brothers as we rode cardboard boxes down a long, steep hill, fished in the stream in the cow pasture, swam in the river, and sat out at the county road trying to sell lemonade to the summer tourists.

What I’m the most thankful for is my husband who early in our marriage realized that I needed to write to not be grouchy. There were times he’d come into the house and say, “When was the last time you wrote something?” When I’d say, “A few days ago.” He’d tell me to go write. I’d drop whatever household chore I was doing and write. It is my happy place and my therapy.

I finished the 9th book in the Spotted Pony Casino Mystery series, Santa’s Beard, last week. It’s with my editor while I’m on a short vacation with hubby. I hadn’t planned on working on the next book in the Gabriel Hawke series until after the first of the year because I have a lot of “marketing” things I need to deal with. But not writing isn’t in me. While I was walking my dog the other day, the beginning of the next book came to me and I’ve written it down. I know it will change several times before I actually start the book, but that’s how my mind works.

Now that the starting point for the next book came to me, I’ll be running things over in my head to find the best beginning and figure out suspects. 😉 One of my favorite parts is putting together the cast of characters who might be the killer. I like to have 4 options for the killer and yet, many times it ends up being someone who I pluck out of the air and don’t realize they are the murderer until I get near the end of the book. I love it when I surprise myself! Especially, when I go back to add in the clues and realize I had added them already. That’s when I’m thankful for my subconscious!

One of the things I’m the most thankful for are the Ladies of Mystery. The authors who post on the blog monthly and share about our guest spots with other authors. Without all their wonderful posts about writing and life, this would be a boring place. Our guest bloggers are mystery and thriller writers from all over and different careers. I love learning about other writers and picking up some good reads.

What I am thankful for the most are the people who follow and read this blog and who purchase our books. Our fans are what keep us writing. Thank you to everyone out there who reads and purchases books whether they are print, ebook, or audio.

If you’d like to stay up to date with my writing or learn about how I became a write, you can subscribe to my Substack. I post all the blog posts from the Ladies of Mystery there, share author friends and their books, and of course, my newest books and sales. https://substack.com/@patyjag

Have a wonderful month and fabulous Thanksgiving!

Guest Blogger ~ M. E. Proctor

Making a Scene

By M.E. Proctor

One of the questions most frequently asked to a writer (on par with where do you get your ideas?) is if they know the entire story from the get go or if they figure it out on the fly—the planners versus the improvisers conversation.

I’m a hybrid. I put together a rough outline and then inevitably veer away from it as I start writing. This happens because I love to work individual scenes. What happens here and now tends to take my attention away from the high level perspective of the complete narrative.

Here’s an example from the new Declan Shaw detective novel, The Way You Say My Name.

In Chapter 4, Declan meets Sam, the local vet. He waits for her in her small office, intending to ask her about an incident with a dog. It’s a critical scene that will set in motion a succession of dramatic events. Declan is attracted to Sam and her reaction is ambiguous. She could put a firm end to his flirting attempts but she doesn’t, leaving him wondering why she’s aloof and what she isn’t telling him.

I must have imagined, pictured, and acted this scene over a dozen times in my head. I moved my actors around and changed their lines of dialogue endlessly until the interaction sounded and felt right. I didn’t sit at the keyboard to write until I was sure I’d nailed it down. This is how I built the book, scene after scene. In editing, with the full story laid out, I reworked parts to smoothen the flow.

I’m a ‘visual’ writer. I need to see the scene to be able to write it. And I need to hear it too. A storyboard with speech bubbles won’t do the trick. Like the movies, maybe closer to stage work. Two characters, face to face. They react to each other, there’s tension, and the story happens.

Here’s a small part of that scene, can you picture it?

“Please take a seat. You’re a detective who wants to talk to me about an injured dog, what’s the catch?”

“Senator Spencer hired me to find his daughter, Amanda. Have you heard about the incident?”

“Vaguely. There was a search and it was called off? Senator Spencer is the closest we have to a celebrity around here.” She sat on the corner of the desk, denim-clad legs swinging. “What does it have to do with the dog?”

They were very close. There was barely any room. If she tipped forward, she would drop in his lap. Declan hoped she would tip and drop, so he could catch her. The office door was open, which alleviated the claustrophobic feeling. Sam Chandler smelled of soap and something medicinal, like a freshly opened jar of multivitamins. It should have put Declan’s thoughts on an antiseptic track, and it did the exact opposite. He pictured her scratching the reception cat under the chin, and his head tilted back in an unconscious reflex. She sat higher than he did, and he had to look up to her, so his neck stretch wasn’t completely ridiculous.

I rolled these lines in my head so many times, I could swear I was in the room with them. The scene is told from Declan’s perspective, but I’m Sam’s head too.

So I am more a plotter than an improviser after all. I’m a compulsive nitpicker who needs to have every detail just so. The kicker is that I do it at the scene level, not knowing in Chapter 4 how it will go to hell in Chapter 6. Not until I get there. I have the general direction: Sam is in serious trouble and Declan will be dragged into it, they’ll be running from people who wish them harm, there will be a painful climax and illusions will be shattered …

But the scenes, ah, the scenes! They take shape in my mind one by one, and I ruminate over them, night after night. The guy holding the clapperboard shouts: Scene 25, Take 6 … 7 … 8 … 32 … until I get it just right.
Isn’t it wonderful that writers have no budget to worry about, and no unionized crew members who need breaks to eat and sleep?

The Way You Say My Name

A Declan Shaw Mystery

A short blurb …
On New Year’s day, P.I. Declan Shaw is hired to investigate a disappearance. Amanda Spencer, a young mother of two, slipped away from a Christmas concert without leaving a clue. What made her run and who is she running from?

While digging up shreds of info from Amanda’s parents and friends, Declan meets Sam Chandler. She’s the kind of woman who stops him in his tracks. Sexy, smart, and complicated. And skilled at keeping secrets. So skilled Declan questions his abilities as a detective. What began as an intriguing missing person case soon shifts into a cross-country pursuit with Sam’s life in the balance.

For once, Declan isn’t the searcher, he’s the one who cannot afford to be found.

“This time Proctor does something remarkable. She pulls back the curtain on Declan Shaw’s past, revealing the trauma that helped shape the man readers have come to know. This is a version of Declan that feels unexpectedly vulnerable, stripping away any illusion of invincibility and replacing it with something infinitely more compelling. His evolution across this series is exceptional, and understanding his history makes his compassion, restraint, and fierce loyalty all the more meaningful. Proctor doesn’t simply give readers another mystery to solve. She gives them a character worth investing in, a man whose imperfections make him impossible not to champion.”

—Teresa Brock for Best Thriller Books

Buy Links:

The Way You say My Name is available in eBook and paperback.

All formats on Shotgun Honey website.

M.E. Proctor was born in Brussels and lives in Texas. She’s the author of the Declan Shaw detective mysteries: Love You Till Tuesday, Catch Me on a Blue Day, The Way You Say My Name. She’s the author of two short story collections, Family and Other Ailments and A Book to Live By, and the co-author of the retro-noirs, Bop City Swing and Kansas City Breakdown. Her fiction has appeared in various magazines and anthologies. She’s a Shamus and Derringer awards short story nominee. Catch Me on a Blue Day was recently nominated for a Shamus Award in the Best Original Paperback P.I. Novel category.

Social Links

Author Website: www.shawmystery.com

On Substack: https://meproctor.substack.com

Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/martine.proctor

Twitter: https://twitter.com/MEProctor3

BlueSky: https://bsky.app/profile/meproctor.bsky.social

Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/proctormartine/

Act Three

Heather Cox Richardson is my favorite historian. I listened to her being interviewed in Ohio and she, as she often does, made a point that I found interesting because it applied to my writing. She said we are the first generations who have twenty to thirty years after our children are grown and we have retired from our day jobs to spend any way we want. I chose writing for my later years adventure.

I never intended to write anything after my beloved AP English teacher humiliated me. I had skipped a grade in elementary school so I was young trying to keep up socially with classmates who had a year’s worth of sophistication and experience on me and I was six feet tall at twelve, in other words, backward, shy, and fifteen…you remember those teenage years…and primed to be easily embarrassed even if there was no need to be.

I loved Mrs. McNabb. And I trusted her, which as it turned out was not a good idea, although I’m sure she liked me and had no idea what she was about to do to me. Perhaps as a high school teacher she should have, though. She said as an exercise she wanted us to write about something personal for her eyes only. She promised she would not let anyone else see what we had written, but it was a way for us to learn how to express emotion in our writing.

My paternal grandparents lived an all-day drive away from us in a tiny town in northern California where there was only one main street still faced with a wooden boardwalk from when it had been a stagecoach stop. I loved our visits. I’d get to walk down the street holding Grandpa’s hand, my imagination thinking I could hear the neighing of horses as they pulled buckboards and coaches into town, to buy malted milk balls in the general store.

One of the best parts of my grandparent’s home was Grandpa’s garden. He had three acres of land, a mini farm, where he grew a myriad of vegetables for the table and for sale. His peas rivaled the malted milk balls in sweetness when we picked them and popped them in our mouths directly from their vines. It was he and those visits which fostered my nascent love of gardening.

He had died a few years before Mrs. McNabb’s assignment and I still missed him terribly. On our last visit to see my grandparents we had dug up a bed of pansies which I found charming and put them in big flat boxes for the ride home. He knew, if I did not, that it would be our last visit and he gave them to me to remember him and our gardening adventures.

When I got home with my treasures, I had carefully planted them in the back yard and nurtured them as best as I could, but they failed to thrive and I was heartbroken to watch them wither. When we came home from his funeral, the pansies were in full, colorful bloom. No one could convince my inner child that he hadn’t stopped by before he left for an afterlife and tended them. That was the intimate story I chose to write about for Mrs. McNabb.

A few days after our assignment, she returned all my fellow students’ papers to them in class. But she didn’t return mine. Instead, she stood at the front of the class and proclaimed one story was so well written and had touched her so much that she had to share it with the class. I shriveled amid my classmates’ giggles as they figured out the story was mine.

I never wrote another thing until I was fifty-nine and decided to write my first book as a game to see if I could connect what I thought was a good opening with a strong ending. I guess the point of this post is to encourage any readers out there who want to write that it is never too late to start. I was still working full time at the beginning of my writing career, although my children were grown and launched, but I wrote when I could. I’ve never regretted my later-in-life decision.

I’ve forgiven Mrs. McNabb for her thoughtless betrayal, but I’ve never forgotten it. I don’t embarrass easily now and don’t care if people giggle at my words. I write because I love to do it and hope some of you enjoy my stories. If you don’t, I’m not an awkward teenager any longer looking to fit in; I can take any response that comes my way.

My newest book. “A Faire to Remember” is out now and available in print and for e-books on Amazon. I’ll be touring online with it beginning on November 11th. Look for posts on my Facebook page ( Nancy Lynn Jarvis) if you want the inside scoop on it or go to my website:  nancylynnjarvis.com to read the first chapter for free.

Dog-Gone, Rats, and Other Classy Words by Heather Haven

When I first started writing mysteries decades ago, I didn’t even know what a cozy was. And when I found out, I never thought I was writing them. Still don’t. A lot of my subjects are fairly dark. In Book 4 of the Alvarez Family Murder Mysteries, DEAD … If Only, the story deals with a rape and child pornography. I don’t beat it into the ground, but these two facts motivate many of the characters’ actions. So, as I say, I never thought of myself as a cozy writer, despite resolutions that end with everyone becoming a B&BP (bigger and better person). However, when my publicist flung me into the cozy mystery category and gave me new covers indicating that’s what I wrote, my sales picked up. Inside, my stories hadn’t changed. Not a single word.  But here I was in the cozy mystery category. That was a real eye-opener for me.

There are levels of darkness in my books that, apparently, the reader can absorb or ignore. Or just deal with as a part of life. Readers are, by and large, a sophisticated lot and often take it as it comes. They accept that I write funny while dealing with serious subjects. In fact, they are often grateful for it. Life can be pretty dark and disturbing. If you have a laugh here and there, so much the better. As far as I can tell, I write the humorous mystery pretending to be a cozy. All right then. I cope and write on.

One day a reader sent me an email saying how glad she was I didn’t use any colorful language in my novels. I thought about it. Well, given the setting, yes I do. Or have. But probably not in the one or two novels she’d read. In one scene from Death Runs in the Family, Lee is helping her ex-husband with a serious problem. His gratitude runs along the lines of using every vulgar word he can think of because he’s that kinda guy. Fed up, Lee tells him nicely to stop talking like that or she’ll stop him and not so nicely. I couldn’t have him say words like gosh-darn it and phooey. It simply wouldn’t work in that setting. I had to use the real stuff to get my point across. But other than that scene, I don’t pepper my dialog with curse words for no other reason than I simply don’t. Now and then, if it’s necessary, I let ‘er rip with a damn or hell. But I try to keep it to a minimum. In my opinion, a plethora of explicatives can take away from the story. That might be all the reader remembers.

This is not just in books, either. A friend of mine returned from the theater the other day and was aghast the musical she’d seen seemed to use the F-word in almost every other sentence. At least, that’s what she took away; not the songs, acting, or choreography. Which is a pity. Unless the book and libretto were lacking and the writers thought they were covering that fact up with shock value. Young comics often hide their inexperience with the world. “Fu-fu-fu-fu-fu” seems to be all I hear. If they think they’re being shocking, they’re not. They are being boring and unimaginative. Give me Seinfeld or Rita Rudner any time.

Recently, I asked myself a question. Could I write a novel without using one single explicative? More to the point, could I substitute a clever word for what society has deemed a curse word and still have it come off as sounding plausible? In my last novel, Cleopatra Almost Slept Here, I found I did it once or twice without realizing it. Here’s a paragraph: Startled, I must have jumped three feet into the air from a sitting position, surpassing any previous record set at the Olympics. This is the problem with relaxing for a moment after a hard afternoon. People tend to sneak up and scare the Rumpelstiltskin out of you. 

Brilliant? No. Entertaining? Hopefully. When I write, I write for me, first and foremost. But I do try to have a mystery sprinkled with the emotions of life wrapped up in a few laughs. And lately, I’ve been trying to keep my explicatives to a minimum because, frankly, I don’t want to be remembered just for them.