When I first started writing mysteries decades ago, I didn’t even know what a cozy was. And when I found out, I never thought I was writing them. Still don’t. A lot of my subjects are fairly dark. In Book 4 of the Alvarez Family Murder Mysteries, DEAD … If Only, the story deals with a rape and child pornography. I don’t beat it into the ground, but these two facts motivate many of the characters’ actions. So, as I say, I never thought of myself as a cozy writer, despite resolutions that end with everyone becoming a B&BP (bigger and better person). However, when my publicist flung me into the cozy mystery category and gave me new covers indicating that’s what I wrote, my sales picked up. Inside, my stories hadn’t changed. Not a single word. But here I was in the cozy mystery category. That was a real eye-opener for me.
There are levels of darkness in my books that, apparently, the reader can absorb or ignore. Or just deal with as a part of life. Readers are, by and large, a sophisticated lot and often take it as it comes. They accept that I write funny while dealing with serious subjects. In fact, they are often grateful for it. Life can be pretty dark and disturbing. If you have a laugh here and there, so much the better. As far as I can tell, I write the humorous mystery pretending to be a cozy. All right then. I cope and write on.
One day a reader sent me an email saying how glad she was I didn’t use any colorful language in my novels. I thought about it. Well, given the setting, yes I do. Or have. But probably not in the one or two novels she’d read. In one scene from Death Runs in the Family, Lee is helping her ex-husband with a serious problem. His gratitude runs along the lines of using every vulgar word he can think of because he’s that kinda guy. Fed up, Lee tells him nicely to stop talking like that or she’ll stop him and not so nicely. I couldn’t have him say words like gosh-darn it and phooey. It simply wouldn’t work in that setting. I had to use the real stuff to get my point across. But other than that scene, I don’t pepper my dialog with curse words for no other reason than I simply don’t. Now and then, if it’s necessary, I let ‘er rip with a damn or hell. But I try to keep it to a minimum. In my opinion, a plethora of explicatives can take away from the story. That might be all the reader remembers.
This is not just in books, either. A friend of mine returned from the theater the other day and was aghast the musical she’d seen seemed to use the F-word in almost every other sentence. At least, that’s what she took away; not the songs, acting, or choreography. Which is a pity. Unless the book and libretto were lacking and the writers thought they were covering that fact up with shock value. Young comics often hide their inexperience with the world. “Fu-fu-fu-fu-fu” seems to be all I hear. If they think they’re being shocking, they’re not. They are being boring and unimaginative. Give me Seinfeld or Rita Rudner any time.
Recently, I asked myself a question. Could I write a novel without using one single explicative? More to the point, could I substitute a clever word for what society has deemed a curse word and still have it come off as sounding plausible? In my last novel, Cleopatra Almost Slept Here, I found I did it once or twice without realizing it. Here’s a paragraph: Startled, I must have jumped three feet into the air from a sitting position, surpassing any previous record set at the Olympics. This is the problem with relaxing for a moment after a hard afternoon. People tend to sneak up and scare the Rumpelstiltskin out of you.
Brilliant? No. Entertaining? Hopefully. When I write, I write for me, first and foremost. But I do try to have a mystery sprinkled with the emotions of life wrapped up in a few laughs. And lately, I’ve been trying to keep my explicatives to a minimum because, frankly, I don’t want to be remembered just for them.

Humorous mystery.
I wonder why that can’t be a genre, if cozy mystery can be.
I wholeheartedly agree with you on the issue of people using and overusing profanity in their work.
LikeLike
Heather, I’m the same way. I didn’t think my Shandra Higheagle mysteries were cozy because of the dark topics, but everyone calls them cozy, so now I do.
And I get emails all the time thanking me for my clean mysteries. Like you, I do use hell, damn, and shit, but it’s like what Susan said: it’s usually used once when something scares the character, and then they pull themselves together. My character Dela in the Spotted Pony Casino mysteries says, “Double-frickin’ shit when we is really mad.
I do have a couple of Hawke books where the villains use the F word, but not all the time, just in moments when a bad person would use it. I can’t stand a song, book, or show that uses the F word all the time. I turn them off or close the book and don’t read it. There is no need to overuse the word. When I hear someone talking like that, I believe they have a limited vocabulary and therefore aren’t very smart.
Fun and good post! Thanks!
LikeLike
I think we have that approach in common, Paty! Thanks for chiming in.
LikeLike
Susan, you and I belong to a mutual admiration society. I just love the way YOU write. And thanks for the validation on this. If the scene warrants it, I will swear like a sailor, I swear. Thanks, Heather
LikeLike
I love the way you write. I could not get through the day without humor. I’ve even been called insensitive (probably fairly) for not being serious enough about certain unfortunate experiences but since they occurred in my life I continue to think it’s okay. I also think when someone is past the immediate shock of whatever has happened and curses, the curses should be done because now comes the time for thinking, acting, facing the challenge. It’s sort of like when I just miss dying in a car crash because some joker thinks he can hit 80 mph on back roads with curves and wants to impress his girlfriend. You can bet I swear as I slam the wheel to the right and try to avoid the ditch in front of me, and then I calm down and try to remember the details of the car and driver. So swear away, and then grab that story and drive. As I know you will.
LikeLike