As readers, I would like to suggest that we have a responsibility to leave reviews, especially if we love the book. Reviews help other readers discover new authors, ones not touted by major publishers but by independent publishers and self-publishers. Getting a good book noticed as an independent (whether publisher or self-publisher) rests almost entirely on the reader’s shoulders. It isn’t hard to leave a review. In fact, most e-books end with the option. And as reviewers, we don’t have to write a treatise explaining what we liked or didn’t like; just assign a star from 1-5 on most sites.
Besides helping the book get noticed and sell, reviews help authors in three ways; 1) eat, 2) improve so that your next reading experience is better, and 3) keep a publisher publishing an author you like.
Unless a book has ten reviews on Amazon, it is at a disadvantage. So, for authors, ten reviews is a decent but frustrating goal. As a publisher and author, I ask that you take the time to give any Bodie Blue Books book a star rating, if not an actual review.
A Common Scale
The biggest challenge to comparing reviews across books is that there is no consistent, holistic scale used across readers. Simply put, each five-star review is given on a personal scale that may not be consistent book to book, much less across genres. For instance, a five-star book may be one you were driven to finish that delivered a rip-snorting solution to the mystery. Others may consider it a three because something was missing for them, even though they finished it in one reading.
Momentary rant: Nothing is more frustrating for the author than to get a great review and a three-star score when the same review written by another reader would result in five stars. Worse, some readers seem to believe that they have the sensibilities of a New York Times book critic. Here is a hint: most don’t. What we do have is an absolute sense of what we enjoy as readers and what annoys us.
Back on topic: I spent a good deal of my business career teaching people how to evaluate student creative writing on a holistic scale. Reviewers were trained to apply a set scale consistently to rank students writing. A simple holistic score is easy to use. Further, it assesses the overall book not that one annoying swear word or mistake in the setting or time, but your overall reading experience. Below are a couple of example scales.
|5||Enjoyed it a lot, could be convinced to love it, a lively entry into the genre.|
|4||Enjoyed it, had elements that I loved, a solid entry in the genre.|
|3||Ahhh, liked it but average for the genre.|
|2||Expected more, below average for the genre|
|1||Argh, got lost in a black hole|
Examples 2 and 3
|5||Loved it.||I can’t wait for the next book from this author|
|4||Enjoyed it.||I look forward to reading this author again|
|3||Okay||I would consider reading this author again|
|2||Readable but . . .||I would have to be convinced to read another book by this author|
|1||Where is my red pencil?||I have banished this author from my brain|
A single holistic scale applied across online book sites would provide buyers a consistent, realistic method to compare books. Not having such a scale supports the dominance of mega-authors with big advertising budgets and faithful fans, not because the books are better, but out of habit and accessibility. This leaves writers who write as good as or better books in the weeds. Because sites, such as Amazon, rely almost entirely on reviews to determine who gets the best placement for advertisements, which books are featured, and which books pop during a genre search.
So, I beg you, when you finish reading a book, leave a review. Until we have a common scale, use your best judgment but be consistent in applying it. And remember, every review you leave helps an author EAT.
3 thoughts on “The Readers’ Responsibility – Valid Reviews”
Good post! It is a long hard journey to get readers to write reviews. As an author if I’m not crazy about a book I read, I just don’t give a review. I’d rather not give the writer a low rating. But if I like a book, I definitely rate and review.
Great post. Definitely food for thought.
Thank you for this post. You said everything that I’ve been thinking, especially the development of a holistic approach that would bring greater uniformity and fairness to the reviewing process.
Comments are closed.